• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Brooke Nicole Larsen
  • New? Start here
  • Home
  • Projects
    • Building
    • Before and After
    • Decorating
    • DIY
    • Furniture
    • Holiday Decorating & Crafts
    • Tutorials
    • About Me
  • Custom Built Home
  • Remodeled Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Newsletter
  • The Instagram Reset
menu icon
go to homepage
search icon
Homepage link
  • New? Start here
  • Home
  • Projects
    • Building
    • Before and After
    • Decorating
    • DIY
    • Furniture
    • Holiday Decorating & Crafts
    • Tutorials
    • About Me
  • Custom Built Home
  • Remodeled Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Newsletter
  • The Instagram Reset
×
Home

Breaking the Mold: Wood Floor Oil Finish vs Polyurethane

Jul 8, 2024 by Brooke Larsen · This post may contain affiliate links · Leave a Comment

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
Wood Floor Oil Finish vs Polyurethane

Discover why wood floor oil finish is becoming the preferred style for hardwood floors.

Move over, polyurethanes. Oil-based finishes are breaking tradition with hardwood flooring poly finishes. In the world of wood floor finishes, the choice between oil and polyurethane can make a significant difference in the overall look and maintenance of your floors.

Let's delve into the unique advantages of wood floor oil finishes over traditional polyurethane coatings. From a more natural appearance to easier upkeep, discover why oil may be the perfect type of finish for elevating the aesthetic and functionality of your hardwood floors.

Wood floor oil finish kitchen

Why I Love My Oiled Floors

The oiled floors in my home have a raw and textured look to them that I love. The natural look helps to hide dirt really well too so if I miss a day or two of regular cleaning. And with an oiled floor, the top coat doesn't scratch. This is super helpful with pets and kids running all over my floors.

But the downsides? These floors can splinter which is not always ideal. You have to oil them every 4 years or so to keep them in good condition. And because these floors are sealed with a wax, it is possible for them to stain if something has spilled and been left for awhile.

Polyurethane floors don't splinter or stain. Plus, they have a more uniform smooth finish. However, the top coat can scratch. And when these floors need to be refinished, it is a larger project because they have to be completely sanded down before adding the polyurethane coating.

master bedroom flooring oil finish

Wood Floor Oil Finish vs Polyurethane

With all the different finishes out there, it's really important to choose the right finish for your flooring. Let's take a look at two popular choices and discover why oil-finished floors may be the best option.

What is an Oil Finish?

  • Oils fortify, seal and penetrate the natural wood surface
  • Keeps the natural look and feel of the wood
  • Shows more texture

I use quality products like this oil to maintain my floor.

What is a Polyurethane Finish?

  • Polyurethanes add a barrier or protective layer over the wood
  • Comes in water-based finishes and oil-based
  • Smoother finish
  • Protects from liquids and surface scratching
Oiled floors in kitchen

Enhanced Natural Beauty

When it comes to enhancing the natural beauty of your hardwood, oil finishes offer a unique advantage over polyurethane coatings. An oil finish highlights the natural grain and color of the wood. So if you love the patterns and textures that come with natural wood, this finish type may be perfect for you. I especially love this look in my kitchen because it balances all of the wood and white tones.

Oil finishes also create a more organic and earthy look. Earthy tones are helpful in lightening up a space. This enhanced natural beauty of the wood can bring warmth and character to any room in your home, setting the stage for a cozy and inviting ambiance.

Natural look wood flooring

Easier Maintenance with Wood Floor Oil Finish

Maintenance is a significant factor to consider when choosing between a wood floor oil finish vs polyurethane coating. With wood finish oil, the upkeep for the oiled floor is much easier and less time-consuming compared to polyurethane. Instead of having to completely sand down and refinish the entire floor when minor damage occurs, the application process for oil finishes allow for spot repairs and touch-ups. This means that maintaining is more manageable and cost-effective over time.

Though you may have to touch up a little more often with oil finishes, the ease of maintenance makes wood floor oil finishes a practical choice. It's especially helpful for busy households or high-traffic areas where wear and tear are inevitable.

Ideal for High-Traffic Areas

I love wood floor oil finishes because they are ideal for high-traffic areas like a family room, kitchen area and hallways. This is due to easy maintenance and ability to withstand daily wear and tear. Whether it's spills, scratches, or heavy foot traffic, the convenience of spot repairs and touch-ups makes for greater flexibility for busy lifestyles.

This low-maintenance option allows for a quick and cost-effective solution to maintaining the beauty of your floors over time. Plus, I can easily touch up with oil on my own time, compared to redoing a polyurethane hardwood floor that is more extensive. For those looking for a flooring solution that can handle the demands of a high-traffic area, wood floor oil finishes provide a convenient and durable option that can extend the life of your floor.

Polyurethane floors

Low Sheen for a Subtle Look

A low sheen wood floor oil finish may be the perfect choice for those wanting an understated, elegant look in their living space. The subtle sheen adds a touch of sophistication to your floors, enhancing the natural beauty of the wood without overwhelming the room.

Do you love a matte finish or subtle shine? This low-key finish is ideal for those who prefer a more muted aesthetic or want to create a cozy and inviting atmosphere in their home. Are you aiming for a rustic farmhouse feel or modern minimalist? This natural finish look on the surface of the wood can complement a variety of design styles and preferences.

Benefits of Wood Floor Oil Finish

Wood floor oil finishes offer a range of unique advantages over traditional polyurethane coatings. From enhancing the natural beauty of your hardwood floors to providing easier maintenance and durability in high-traffic areas, oil finish is a versatile choice for any home.

Embrace the beauty of a low sheen, subtle look by choosing oil finish for your flooring. Make the switch and experience the timeless elegance and simplicity of a natural look in your flooring project.

Happy Decorating!

Brooke

More Decorating

  • entryway decor
    12 + Year-Round Entryway Decor Ideas to Welcome Every Season (and Holiday!)
  • living room pouf
    10 Creative Pouf Ideas to Style in Your Home
  • 20 Stunning Table Centerpieces for Every Season
  • Window treatments
    10+ Unexpected Ways to Use Window Treatments in Your Home
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

About Brooke Larsen

Hello Friends! I love anything DIY and home decorator! On my blog I hope you will find home inspo. Whether it is for your next DIY project or home decor. If I can do it, anyone can!

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Hi I am Brooke I am an avid DIY-er and home decorator! I share home inspo and all of my DIY projects with step-by-step directions. I sprinkle in a few recipes to help out all of us busy moms too. If I can do it, so can you!

More about me →

Popular

  • valentine envelope gift
    Create a Cute Valentine Gift Using an Oversized Envelope
  • moody brown paint
    The Top 15 Moody Brown Paint Colors for Your Home (2026 Guide)
  • valentine's lollipop
    How to Make a Giant Valentine Lollipop (Easy + So Cute!)
  • Perfect christmas bow
    How to Tie the Cutest Bows (6 Easy Bow Ideas Anyone Can Do)
  • New? Start here
  • Home
  • Projects
  • Custom Built Home
  • Remodeled Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Newsletter
  • The Instagram Reset

Copyright © 2026 Brooke Nicole Larsen on the Seasoned Pro Theme

15 shares